sister asked a question the non-muslim
sister that there are some verses of the
Quran which are abrogating a
contradicting it's cancelled so does it
mean that how can there be
contradiction if you read the Quran
there is there is there are no two
verses in the Quran which contradict I
challenge anyone to point out any two
vers in the Quran which contradict Allah
says clearly in the Quran inaha chapter
number four verse number 82 Allah says
do they not consider the Quran with care
had it been from anyone besides Allah
there would have been many
contradictions now in the Muslim umah
I'm aware there is a concept of
abrogation theory of abrogation known as
manuk and based on the verse of the
Quran of Surah Bak chapter 2 verse 106
and Surah chapter number 16 verse number
101 which says that that Allah subhana
wa ta'ala does not cause any of his
ayats any of his signs to be forgotten
he substitutes it with something better
or
similar now based on this ver there are
many scholars who have propounded the
theory of
abrogation N and
manuk people say what is Dr talking
about that no ver is contradict the
Quran says the ver will not
contradict it will not contradict any
scholar says anything I'm not bothered
Allah is the highest number one now if
you read the verse of the Quran you can
you can analyze the verse of the Quran
in two ways one way is that the ayat
talking in the Quran are referring to
the earlier
scriptures maybe Torah maybe injil so
Allah says I do not cause any of the
Ayah the signs of Allah the previous
vers of the previous Revelation to be
forgotten but substituted with something
better or
similar something better and similar is
the
Quran no if you agree that the ayat
mentioned in the verse is ayats of the
Quran then to I have an answer it means
that Allah subhana wa ta'ala has
revealed one verse of the Quran what was
relevant for that time and after that he
revealed another verse but that verse is
not contradicting it is giving more
information and the two verses given by
the sister of Surah n 4:1 15 and Sur n
chapter number 24 ver number two though
she hasn't mentioned the transl
and by Allah's Grace I know the
translation of these verses not that
Quran this is all training it's not
Quran it is practice that I know what
question are going to come to me so we
know the verses mallah it's very easy
it's not difficult you tell the verses
and even our children Mah do the same
alhamdulillah Sur n chapter number four
verse number 15
says
that if anyone is caught in fornication
if any woman is caught in fornication
ation then keep her in custody in house
arrest like seclude her until she dies
or Allah ordained something else and
then Surah n chapter number 24 verse
number two says that as for the
fornicator person who commits
fornication give them punishment of 100
lashes now people will think is there a
contradiction if the first quranic verse
of Sur n chter 4 15 and said that put
the woman in house arrest and a full
stop then Sur n of 100 lashes would
contradict it says that keep them in
house until they die or until Allah
gives something else now for this Allah
Quran for a fornicator there's 100 lash
and in the Hadith of bukari for the
adulterer the punishment is thr into
that so this verse of the Quran does say
that Allah will give some other
punishment later on
if that part wasn't there there would
have been a contradiction so there's no
contradiction it says that this
punishment is
temporary later on Allah will reveal
something else similarly there are
Scholars who have written that there are
thousand verses contradicting some
Scholars then came to 500 Su I think
came down to 22 another scholar came
down to five I have verified those 22
and five also I have answered those also
alhamdulillah and one of them is this
what we realize what Quran says
according to mean in manuk and what it
happens that Allah in some prohibitions
he has bought stages and the best
example I give is of alcohol the first
verse to be revealed regarding alcohol
is Surah Bak chap 2 vers 219 where Allah
says in
intoxicant there is loss as well as
prophit the loss is more than
prophit this verse of the Quran does not
prohibit alcohol it only says in
intoxicant there is loss and Prophet the
loss is more than Prophet the next verse
to be revealed of prohibition was Surah
n 443 which says that do not pray with
your mind befogged when you're
intoxicated do not pray that means it's
a higher degree now previously did not
say it was Haram it only gave you
guidance in intoxicant there is loss and
Prophet loss is more than Prophet next
was say Do not pray with your mind
before when you're intoxicated you can't
pray now since a Muslim has to pray five
times a day indirectly he can't pray he
can't have intoxicated the full
day in night option is there not it
thing you should have the final Haram
prohibition came in 5 verse number 19
which
says oh you
believe most certainly intoxic and
gambling dedication of stone divination
of
Arrow these are
sat abstain from this handwork that you
may Prosper here the final prohibition
came now when this verse was revealed
barrels of alcohol intoxicant were
thrown on the streets of Madina never to
be filled again then the final Haram
came now if you analyze many people say
that the last verse of Sur MAA CH 5 vers
number 90 has
overruled Sur Bak CH 2 ver 19 is
contradicting it's not
contradicting it is giving more
information the first verse only told
you there is loss and prophit loss is
more even today the verse is applicable
that verse is even correct today even in
intoxicant today there is loss and
profit we as medical doctors know there
is profit but the loss is more than
profit the next ver says
Don't Pray when you're intoxicated even
today that is applicable today you
cannot
Pray when you're intoxicated but the
last final prohibition doesn't
contradict it
encompasses for example I say that I
live in
UK fine then next day I say I live in
London third day I say I live in Harrow
now moment I say Harrow London and UK is
understood but my first answer I live in
UK was a general answer then more
specific I live in London when I say
live in Harrow it is more specific it's
not contradicting my first answer so the
last prohibition that the alcohol is
prohibited is not contradicting that in
intoxicant there is loss and profit it
is yet there it's not contradictory 4:43
you cannot Pray when you are before F
when your mind is be fogged when you're
intoxicated so this means there is more
information the last verse of the Quran
if you follow that the earlier two is
automatically followed it's understood
so therefore according to me and
according to Allah subhana tala there is
not a single contradiction in the Quran
if there were any contradiction this
book cannot be the word of Allah subhana
tala so I disagree with anyone let him
be the greatest caller in the world
according to me and has challenge anyone
whether Muslim or non-muslim to point
out a single contad in the Quran they
will never do it and never will be able
to do it
[Applause]